Skip to content
All articles

Technology

The First-Pass Submittal Review Problem: How AI Is Changing What Gets Caught Early

The most expensive submittal mistakes aren't caught late — they were never caught in the first pass. AI-assisted review is changing what gets found before materials are fabricated or delivered to site.

· 10 min read

Every construction project involves a submittal process, and almost every project team will tell you that the submittal process takes longer than it should. Product data, shop drawings, samples, certifications, calculations, installation details, and warranty documentation must be reviewed against the contract documents before materials are fabricated, ordered, or installed. A submittal review error that reaches the field — a product that does not meet the specified performance requirement, a shop drawing that does not coordinate with the structural framing, an installation detail that conflicts with an adjacent system — can result in rework, delay, procurement disruption, and in some cases, removal and replacement of installed work. The cost of a missed submittal discrepancy discovered in the field is typically five to ten times higher than the cost of the same discrepancy discovered during review. The incentive to improve first-pass review quality is therefore significant. The challenge is that first-pass review is exactly where the most time pressure falls — and where the most manual, repetitive comparison work is concentrated. AI is beginning to change what gets caught in that first pass.

What a First-Pass Review Actually Involves

A thorough first-pass submittal review involves more steps than most people outside the design and engineering professions realize. The reviewer must confirm that the submittal addresses the specification section and paragraph identified in the cover transmittal, verify that the submitted product matches the specified manufacturer, model, or approved equal, compare performance data — capacity, efficiency, dimensions, weight, electrical characteristics, structural properties, or thermal values — against the specified minimums and maximums, check whether any deviations from specified requirements are identified and flagged by the submitter, confirm that all required documentation is included — data sheets, test reports, certifications, installation instructions, warranties, and cut sheets — review dimensional information for coordination with architectural, structural, mechanical, electrical, and plumbing drawings, identify whether the submittal affects or is affected by any open RFIs or previously approved substitutions, and determine whether the submittal requires referral to a consultant discipline for review. On a complex mechanical unit, structural connection, or specialty façade system, a single submittal may require comparing hundreds of data points against the contract documents. This is not work that benefits from speed alone — it benefits from thoroughness, and thoroughness is time-consuming when done manually.

Where First-Pass Reviews Break Down

First-pass reviews break down for several predictable reasons. Review time is frequently compressed by construction schedules. A product may have a long fabrication lead time, which means the submittal must be reviewed and approved before the schedule has any apparent urgency — and so it waits. When the schedule pressure finally arrives, the review is rushed, and the thoroughness that was available earlier is no longer practical. Review responsibility may also be fragmented, with different sections of a submittal reviewed by different team members or consultants who are not always communicating. A mechanical engineer may review the equipment performance data without being aware that the structural engineer identified a weight concern on the same unit. Submittals containing large volumes of documentation may not be fully read. A reviewer under time pressure may verify the model number and a few key performance figures while missing a dimensional discrepancy buried in a technical table. Contractors may also submit incomplete packages — missing certifications, omitting required calculations, or providing generic product data instead of project-specific shop drawings — without flagging the omission clearly. When reviewers return a submittal for resubmission after discovering a missing document, the entire review cycle restarts, consuming additional weeks.

What AI Does in the Comparison Step

The most direct application of AI in submittal review is the comparison step — the process of extracting product data from a submittal and comparing it against the specification. A well-designed AI system can read a product data sheet or shop drawing, extract key values — dimensions, capacities, efficiencies, ratings, certifications, electrical characteristics, materials — and compare each value against the requirements of the applicable specification section. For example, if a specification requires a centrifugal pump with a minimum flow rate of 250 gallons per minute, a maximum motor power of 15 horsepower, a head of 60 feet, and NSF 61 certification for potable water, the AI can check each of those requirements against the submitted product data and flag any item that does not meet the specification or is not clearly documented. On a project with dozens of equipment submittals, this type of comparison work can consume 10 to 20 hours of engineering time per week. AI can compress that initial extraction and comparison into minutes, allowing the reviewer to focus on the items that actually require professional judgment: interpreting a discrepancy, determining whether a deviation is acceptable, and deciding how the response should be worded.

Identifying Missing Documents Automatically

One of the most consistent sources of submittal delays is incomplete documentation. A specification section may require a product data sheet, an installation instruction manual, a test report demonstrating compliance with a referenced standard, an energy-efficiency certification, a structural calculation stamped by a licensed engineer, a sample for approval, and a warranty document — and the submitter may provide only three of the seven. A reviewer who manually works through a complex package may not catch every missing item, particularly if the package is large, the review time is short, or the specification has been modified from a standard format. An AI system that has been trained to read specification requirements and cross-reference them against the contents of a submittal package can generate a completeness checklist automatically — identifying which required items are present and which are missing before the reviewer begins the technical review. Returning a submittal for missing documents before beginning the substantive review is faster and less disruptive than discovering a missing calculation three weeks into a review cycle.

Drawing Coordination and Dimensional Checks

Shop drawing review presents a more complex challenge than product data review because it involves comparing a contractor-prepared drawing against a design document — and the drawing may cover dimensions, connections, interfaces, clearances, loads, installation sequences, and coordination with adjacent systems. AI tools with the ability to parse drawing geometry and extract dimensional data can help flag the most common coordination problems: a piece of equipment that is wider than the specified clearance, a duct that conflicts with a structural beam, a pipe that routes through a space reserved for electrical conduit, or an anchor bolt pattern that does not match the structural drawing. These conflicts are not always visible without cross-referencing multiple drawing sets simultaneously — which is precisely the type of review step that is routinely abbreviated when schedule pressure is high. AI cannot replace a reviewing engineer's judgment about whether a coordination conflict is significant or how it should be resolved — but it can identify which conflicts exist so that the engineer can make that judgment efficiently.

Structuring the Review Response

Once a review analysis is complete, the response must be documented clearly. A well-structured submittal review comment identifies the specification reference, describes the discrepancy or missing item, explains what is required, and states whether the submittal is approved, approved as noted, revise and resubmit, or rejected. AI can help draft review comments in a consistent format, organizing findings into categories — compliant items, minor comments, deviations requiring resolution, missing documentation, and coordination issues requiring multi-discipline review. Consistency in review comments reduces back-and-forth with the submitter. A comment that says 'revise' without specifying what needs to be revised creates another round of correspondence. A comment that identifies the exact specification clause, the specific discrepancy, and the exact revision required allows the submitter to act immediately. This consistency is especially valuable on large projects where multiple reviewers are handling different submittal categories — AI can help ensure that the response format and level of specificity are uniform across the entire submittal log.

The Substitution and Approved-Equal Problem

One of the most consequential and frequently contested areas of submittal review is the substitution or approved-equal request. When a specified product is unavailable, out of budget, or proposed to be replaced with an alternate the contractor prefers, the review process must determine whether the proposed substitute meets the intent of the specification and is genuinely equivalent in performance, quality, compatibility, and maintainability. This is a judgment call, and it belongs to the design professional. But AI can support the evaluation by extracting the performance data from both the specified product and the proposed substitute, organizing a side-by-side comparison, identifying where the substitute exceeds the specification, where it falls short, and where it introduces variables not covered by the specification. It can also check whether a similar substitution was previously approved or rejected on the same or related specification sections. The reviewing architect or engineer can then make the decision with a complete analytical summary in front of them rather than assembling that comparison manually.

Accountability, Liability, and the Limits of AI Review

Submittal review carries professional and contractual liability. An architect or engineer who issues a submittal action stamp — approved, approved as noted — is making a professional representation that the submitted materials have been reviewed for general conformance with the design intent. That representation cannot be delegated to an AI system. The reviewing professional must understand what the AI analysis did and did not check, verify that the sources are accurate and current, apply independent judgment to discrepancies and deviations, and take responsibility for the final action stamp. AI tools that automatically return submittal responses without professional review create legal and technical risks that far outweigh any time savings they may appear to offer. There is no shortcut to the professional review step in submittal management. The purpose of AI is to make the preparation for that step faster, more thorough, and better organized — not to substitute for it. Project teams that implement AI submittal tools should establish clear policies confirming that no submittal action is issued without review and approval by the responsible design professional.

Measuring the Impact

The construction industry does not yet have large-scale published studies on the specific time savings produced by AI-assisted submittal review, partly because the technology is relatively new and adoption is still early-stage. However, firms that have piloted AI review tools on commercial and industrial projects have reported reductions in first-pass review preparation time of 40 to 60 percent for product data submittals and 20 to 35 percent for shop drawing reviews, alongside meaningful improvements in consistency and completeness of review comments. The larger gains tend to occur on projects with high submittal volumes, well-organized specification and document sets, and reviewers who are willing to use the AI draft as a starting point rather than ignoring it and beginning from scratch. Organizations that have invested in structured specification writing — using consistent section formats, clearly defined submittal requirements, and precise performance criteria — see the greatest benefit, because the AI comparison is only as reliable as the specification it compares against.

Conclusion

The first-pass submittal review is where the highest-value quality control work happens — and where time pressure, manual comparison effort, and fragmented documentation most frequently allow mistakes to pass through. AI-assisted review does not change who is responsible for that quality control. It changes how much time the responsible reviewer can dedicate to judgment rather than to searching, extracting, comparing, and formatting. When an AI system can check a thousand data points against the specification in seconds, and present the reviewer with a structured summary of what complies, what is missing, and what requires a decision, the reviewer can focus entirely on making that decision well. That is a meaningful improvement — not because it makes submittal review easier, but because it makes it more thorough. And on a construction project, a submittal discrepancy caught during review is always cheaper than one caught after the materials arrive on site.

Your next RFI, already drafted

See it on your own project.

PlanSpan prepares cited RFI responses and first-pass submittal reviews from your own drawings and specifications. Start free with one project.